Monday, June 8, 2009

Let's Stop Obsessing About OTA Attendance

Mike Sherman used to say it. Mike McCarthy does, too. And ne'er have words rung truer at OTA time.

"We can't worry about the guys that aren't here. We're going to worry about the guys that are here."

And yet, we've spent the last two weeks stressing about the hidden and furtive agendas of Donald Driver and Nick Collins, who chose to skip at least the first week of OTA's. And since both apparently have contract concerns, the media has speculated endlessly about what they are feeling, what message they are trying to send, and what this means for the future.

We've seen fans post concerns about a veteran team leader like Driver, and even calls to trade Nick Collins before it is too late. And yet, in the end, Driver showed up for Week 2 OTA's, and Collins' absence was vindicated with the unfortunate death of his father in Florida due to cancer.

Now, I've been accused of having a Pleasantville view of how the "good ol' days" used to be, but I don't recall attendance at OTA's being as much of an issue years ago. It seemed like if someone didn't show up, even over a contract issue, the story was "the OTA's are optional" and "we will expect them at the start of training camp". And that was it.

And, I realize a lot of it has to do with the instant access many of us expect from today's mainstream and blogging media sites. We eat it up.

But, I also go back to what, to me, was a turning point in OTA attendance, and that was the yearly hullabaloo over Brett Favre's attendance at them. In the mid-2000's, there were some pretty critical voices of Favre, and one of the items tossed out there was whether or not he was a bad teammate because he didn't attend OTA's.

Now, there are many players that don't attend OTA's, often because they are older veterans who want more time with their family and know what they need to do to get into playing shape. Charles Woodson, one of our most veteran leaders on the team, still does not attend OTA's.

But Favre's situation was always overmagnified. In 2005, criticism abounded as Favre eschewed OTA's, and the fans and media relentlessly questioned it. In response, Favre announced he was working with a core trainer at his home to make sure everyone knew not only that he was working out, but how he was working out.

How many players are required to provide a detailed synopsis of their offseason regiment to the media and fans?

The following year, the media reported daily on whether or not Favre was in attendance at each day's OTA, mostly because new coach Mike McCarthy announced that he had expected Favre to attend 10 of 14 of the minicamp sessions. Yet amusingly enough, they were forced to also announce plenty of other veterans that were missing OTA's, too.

And yet, does McCarthy announce the number of OTA's he expects each player to attend prior to their start?

Do I say this in defense of Favre, especially as his storyline continues to develop today? No. I bring it up because it seemed to mark a new, unintended standard by those loudly making it an issue. At the time, I pointed out that those who were so vociferous in painting Favre as a Bad Teammate because he missed OTA's were setting a double standard for players in the future, who would eventually be judged by the same criteria.

And so here we are, instead of obsessing on whether or not Favre is in attendance, we are obsessing over Nick Collins and Donald Driver, only to find out later that their reasons for missing were valid. The OTA's are voluntary, and while it is certainly in the best interest for players to attend (especially a low-IQ guy like Collins who is supposed to be burning the midnight oil learning his new defensive scheme), they will suffer their own consequences, if any, for not being there.

And, in reality, the guy we probably should be most concerned about is the guy who is in attendance, Aaron Kampman. But, even though he appears clearly put out over the new defense and his new role, he has shown up for each practice. He's a pro. And like the Mikes say, we should be worrying about the guys who are here, not the ones who aren't.

Every Frankenstein's Monster has to be created, and when you look at Brett Favre today, it's not hard to see why he feels the world revolves around him. A great example is the day-to-day reports on whether or not Brett Favre was at OTA's. Did McCarthy excuse him? What is he doing to stay in shape? Does his attendance or lack thereof make him a bad teammate? How is he supposed to be helping his teammates learn the offense when he isn't even there? Will he be there tomorrow?

That kind of obsession, positive or negative, isn't good for anyone.

So, my advice is this: let's allow Collins and Driver (and Woodson and whomever else) to miss the OTA's without obsessing about it. When training camp rolls around, we'll find out how big of an issue they have (and how much they missed in not coming).

The last thing we would want to do is make Nick Collins start believing the world revolves whether or not he comes to OTA's or not. Been there already.

Packers Lounge Needs Help

Save The Lounge

Brandon and Dale have fallen on hard times and their Packer site is being foreclosed on. We're all Packer fans, and if you can spare a dime to help out, please do.

It's really been an amazing journey looking at the expanse of the Packer Blogosphere. So many Packer fans out there, and they've created so many different communities that appeal to groups of those fans. Not every site is the same, and many of them tend to cater to the folks that frequent them. But, its those differences that help us all find our own virtual "Packer Bar" to hang out at online.

Some may prefer the loud bar with chair flying overhead, while others prefer that quieter bar with folks telling their stories about the glory days. But on game day, we all stand united as Packer fans, bleeding green and gold.

Sunday, June 7, 2009

Erratic Pack: Another Roller Coaster in 2009?

While serving as a panelist in the very awesome Cheesehead Nation Blogcast last week, I responded to a poll question that has since given me a lot of consternation. The question in and of itself is simple enough: how many wins do you expect the Packers to have in 2009?

In my eternal objectivity, I predicted an 8-8 record this upcoming year. I justified it on the belief that the Packers were not as bad as last year's 6-10 record would suggest, but also acknowledging that the 3-4 transition and continued flux along the offensive line would dampen any major improvements.

Fair enough. But, I then also looked at my very poor track record in predicting the Packers' win totals the past four seasons.

2005: Coming off a 10-6 season, but with a new GM and lost free agents, I predict 9 wins. The Packers go 4-12.

2006: Given the new regime of MM and a rebuilding effort, I predict 6 wins. The Packers go 8-8.

2007: Believing the Packers are improving, but that the four-game win streak that ended 2006 was against poor competition, I predict 7 wins. The Packers go 13-3.

2008: Thinking the Packers were good, but captured lightning in a bottle in 2007, I predict 10 wins. The Packers go 6-10.

This trip down memory lane led me to two conclusions: number one, don't trust my predictions.

But the second conclusion was more thought-provoking: the Packers have been highly erratic over the past five seasons. There certainly hasn't been much consistency from season to season, at least as far as the final record is concerned. I mean, from 10 wins down to 4, then back up to 13, then down again?

You might be just as accurate by throwing darts blindfolded as trying to scientifically predict how the Packers will do in an upcoming season. So, exactly, how erratic have the Packers been?

Well, if you take the seasons I mentioned, 2004-2008, and look at the difference in wins from season to season, The Packers end up with a total of 22 differential points (10 to 4 (6), 4 to 8 (4), 8 to 13 (5), and 13 to 6 (7)....6+4+5+7 = 22). This means that the Packers, on average, will see their record change by 5.5 wins per season over the last five years.

That's a lot of ups and downs, but how does it compared to other teams in the league? Is this just a symptom of leaguewide parity, in which every team experiences rags to riches followed by a "penthouse to outhouse" soon thereafter?

I did the same analysis with all the other teams in the league over the same time frame, and in the end, the Packers are indeed one of the most inconsistent teams in the league.

In fact, only three teams had more differential points: Baltimore (24), Miami (23), and, ironically, the Jets (23). This means that the Ravens, on average, see their record change by 6 wins each year.

Now, consistency isn't necessarily a good thing or a bad thing. You can be consistently good (like the Colts, who had only 6 differential points) or consistently bad (like the Raiders, who also had only 6 differential points). The difference is that the Colts averaged a little over 12 wins per season, while the Raiders averaged only four. The Colts were consistently good, and the Raiders were consistently bad.

And like the Packers, the Jets, Ravens, and Dolphins have mixed in some exciting playoff seasons with some miserable losing seasons in a short span of time. As you might expect, all four teams seem to be riding a roller coaster the past few years. The Dolphins went from 1-15 to 11-5 last year, accounting for 10 of their 23 differential points.

So, what does this mean? Statistically speaking, the average number of differential points over the past five seasons in the NFL is 13.5, or an average change of a little over three wins per year. The Packers' 22 differential points places them outside the first standard deviation (+5.08, or 18.5 differential points) and nearly outside the second (23.5 dp). If you are a numbers guy, the Packers are well outside "the norm" in terms of lack of consistency.

But, is it a big deal that the Packers are particularly erratic the past few years? Can the big highs and lows be explained off easily enough? Or, are we really in a club with the Jets and Dolphins?

Obviously, the progressive regime change from 2004-2006 didn't do the Packers any favors, and it is also noted that the Packers have undergone a tremendous overhaul of the Mike Sherman roster in 2004, mostly through the draft. The ups and down can easily be attributed to an organization that is trying to muster up some major changes and shakeups over that time period (note: we're going on our fourth DC since 2004).

But that brings us to the ups and downs on the McCarthy era, from 8 wins to 13 to 6, and begs the question as to what we should expect in 2009: if the Packers tend to move 5 wins in one direction or another each season, is it logical to expect an 11-5 season, based on the data?

Certainly, it makes my prediction of an 8-8 season seem to be (again) very conservative. And there are a lot of positive factors that would contribute towards why the Packers could indeed have a division-winning season, from the addition of Dom Capers to the revitalization of the defense, to another year of growth from A-Rodge and getting a lot of key players off the injury list and back on the field.

But, as I postulated a while back, perhaps one of these seasons was an aberration. Perhaps this is a team on the rise (8 wins to 13 wins), marred with a lot of offseason distractions, injuries, and defensive disarray that makes 2008 the exception. Or, perhaps this is a very average team (8 wins and 6 wins) that happened to get extremely lucky and injury-free in 2007.

The unusual wins differential per season is present even under McCarthy's regime (12 differential points since 2006, bested only by Baltimore, Detroit, and Miami). What will be interesting to see is if the Packers even out over the next few seasons and play more consistently each year. Again, consistency in and of itself can be good or bad...it will depend if the Packers end up being consistently around .500 each year, or consistently between 10-13 wins each year.

Or, perhaps, the Packers will continue to be one of the most erratic teams in the league, which isn't all bad, either. I'm sure that fans of the 49ers, Lions, and Raiders would welcome at least one winning season every three years or so.

Differential Points by team (sum of changes in record year-to-year from 2004-2008)

Baltimore 24
Miami 23
NY Jets 23
Green Bay 22
Detroit 18
Tampa Bay 18
Chicago 16
Cleveland 16
Jacksonville 16
Kansas City 16
New Orleans 16
Seattle 15
New England 15
Washington 14
San Diego 14
Philadelphia 14
Atlanta 14
Carolina 13
NY Giants 12
Dallas 11
Houston 11
Pittsburgh 11
Tennessee 10
St. Louis 10
Denver 10
Cincinnati 10
San Francisco 9
Minnesota 8
Buffalo 6
Indianapolis 6
Oakland 6
Arizona 5