Sunday, June 21, 2009

Rodgers Wins the Battle, But War Still In Question...

BigSnakeMan over at PocketDoppler opined an article comparing the new gunslinging quarterbacks in the division to the far more disciplined ("safe"?) Aaron Rodgers here in Green Bay. As far as Snake is concerned, the Packers are a step ahead of our division rivals, as Rodgers is not only takes care of the ball, but will be a year deep in the offense and, as Matt Loede at PackerGab reports via the MJS, will have more of a command of it, too.

From Doppler:

Favre contends that his familiarity with the Vikings system will make him more effective than he was in New York but, like Cutler in Chicago, he will be throwing to receivers who remain largely unproven.

Meanwhile, back in Green Bay, reports coming out of minicamp are saying that head coach Mike McCarthy will open up more of the playbook now that his starting quarterback has a year of experience under his belt. So, while rivals Favre and Cutler under the best of conditions will still be facing transitional seasons, Rodgers should get better in his second year under center. That can only work to the Packers advantage.


And, adding to that, from the MSJ via Loede:

Packers QB Aaron Rodgers had limitations on his audibles last season, but it appears he is going to have more options at his disposal this season. Rodgers believes he is going to be given more responsibility at the line of scrimmage this season because the coaching staff trusts him more. There were times he played like a system quarterback last year, but his teammates told him to let loose a bit.


I have several thoughts on this:

1) I tried to make the case a couple times that Rodgers was playing within the system last year, but usually got pooh-poohed from some of his staunch supporters in the face of all the Favre hubbub. And, I understand that: Rodgers sure didn't any more pressure or criticism last year, particularly from Packer fans.

But now that he has endured his trial by fire, it is time to allow Rodgers to grow and develop, for us to cheer his accomplishments and point out his flaws, just as we would with any other player.

2) Assuming that Rodgers was playing within the system, that usually does tend to build up some very efficient statistics. However, one of the biggest criticisms that arose from last season was the seeming inability of Rodgers to pick up the team lead them on a game-winning drive at the end of the game. Whether you agree with that or not, you have to agree that playing from behind in the fourth quarter has to entail a larger degree of risk-taking on the quarterback's part. While Rodgers appeared willing and ready to take the team on his shoulders at the end of a game, the results were less than shining.

So, 2009 is going to be a pretty strong test of the development and the maturing of Rodgers as a quarterback who can lead this team. It's a good sign he may be given more ability to expand the offense and have more control at the line. The more interesting development will be what he does with that control in the game.

3) The idea that Favre in Minnesota and Cutler in Chicago will be "behind" Rodgers is a bit misleading. First of all, I would far rather have Rodgers than the other two, regardless. I don't think Favre will be able to stand up to another full season of wear and tear, and I don't think Cutler's psyche will survive the Chicago scrutiny.

But to take that as some sort of great advantage for the Packers is looking in the wrong place. The Packers easily had the best quarterback in the division last year and finished well behind both the Bears and the Vikes.

In fact, the threat of a gunslinging quarterback may actually...believe it or not...work in the favor of the Bears and Vikings against the Packers' defense. It's a bit of irony that Snake gives Rodgers such an advantage for being a year ahead of Cutler and Favre, when our defense is still being re-schemed with a lot of question marks.

The weaknesses of the 3-4 defense come in a couple of places:

A) Teams that have strong downhill run games with strong offensive linemen may find success against the front three of the 3-4, forcing the inside linebackers to have to not only make more tackles on the wrong side of the line of scrimmage, but to shed blockers to get there.

B) Teams that have a very fast passing game may also find success against the 3-4. Corners have to be physical at the line of scrimmage with receivers, and linebackers have to play their coverage responsbilities very tightly.

C) The front three of the 3-4 cannot not generate significant pressure on the quarterback on their own, and thus rely on the misdirection of the zone blitzes to create pressure in the backfield.

The problem for the Packers is that they have a lot of question marks in each of these areas.

In A, both the Bears and the Vikings are blessed with strong running backs (Forte and Peterson) and strong offensive linemen. Our front three is quite unproven, with Ryan Pickett's ability to play nose tackle yet to be seen, and BJ Raji is still just a rookie with a lot of room to grow. Our interior linebackers, Hawk and Barnett, are good tacklers but we have yet to see how well they do shedding linemen to get there.

Don't believe me? Check out this quote from Ray Lewis when the Ravens dropped the 3-4.

"We're in the 46 defense now, and finally, finally again, I get to play football," said Lewis. "My job is not to take on offensive linemen, but to make running backs not want to play against me"


In situation B, we still have some confusion as to how our corners are going to play against the receivers. By most accounts, the Packers are going away from their traditional press coverage and strict man-to-man to the 3-4 zone. If an opponent, such as the Vikings, are able to force the Packers defense to respect the run, a quick gunslinging passing game could really hurt them. The selection of Percy Harvin, a troubled but highly fast and explosive receiver, by the Vikings in the draft this offseason suddenly seems to have more of a method to the madness.

And certainly, you have to think Cutler could be much better for Devin Hester than what he's had.

Finally in C, while I am fully encouraged by the reports of how the Packers plan to generate a pass rush in the complicated schemery of Dom Capers, it still stands to reason that the Packers have been lacking in generating a pass rush with a four-man front the past several years (from 46 sacks in 2006, to 36 in 2007, to 27 sacks last year). Since the Packers rarely blitzed under the Bob Sanders scheme, it would stand to reason that the Packers will have to send at least one linebacker or corner into the backfield to generate a strong pass rush.

Which again, plays directly into the other weaknesses of the 3-4 defense. Overplay the pass rush and the running game, and the quick passing game can kill you.

So, while I am fully in agreement with Snake that the Packers are by far in the best position when it comes to who the quarterback is under center in the NFC North, those quarterbacks don't play against each other. It is going to be how those quarterbacks match up against the other teams' defenses.

I see Rodgers growing and maturing, and hopefully contributing towards and improvement of the Packers' splits against these two teams last year.

But to dismiss Favre or Cutler as gunslingers isn't taking into effect who is playing around them, who is going to be taking the handoffs behind them, and particularly, how effective the defenses they play against will be.

There's plenty of time and room for discussion and debate on these points, but let's finish off with one point that we should all agree with: everybody is going to have a lot to prove to each other in the NFC North in 2009. I can't wait to see it all unfold.

Saturday, June 20, 2009

My Pipe Dream: Season Tickets

It will probably never happen in my lifetime, and if it happens to my kids, it will be when they are likely old and grey. But then, at least they'll be able to pass them on to my grandkids.

The Press-Gazette published an article today regarding the long, long wait for season ticket holders...a wait so long now that it estimated to be in the hundreds of years from the time your name gets on the list to the day when it eventually reaches #1.

I sit presently somewhere around #31,384. My kids, who were placed on the list before they were even born, sit right behind me. I figure at the rate the season tickets turn over, I should get mine in about 120 years. Assuming modern medicine doesn't take a quantum leap as it deals with geriatrics, I won't be around to collect on them.

The article places the primary focus of blame on the Packers' inheritance policy, which allows ownership of the tickets to pass from generation to generation, leaving rabid fans on the list out in the cold.

I have little problem with passing the tickets on, however. They are an asset, a prized possession, an heirloom of sorts. There's a lot of pride to be able to say you are sitting in the same seat that your father sat in, and his father sat in. I have a lot of respect for that.

Where I lose respect, however, is when those people are not sitting on those seats, but instead scalping them off to brokers, eBay, or on the street to those rabid fans. The tickets are no longer prized possessions or heirlooms, but investments: buy low, sell high, make a profit off other people's passions.

Of course, that opens up a whole new can of worms. In today's economic depression and concerns over socialistic reforms to laissez-faire, is placing a "scalper tax" on tickets prohibiting a red-blooded American from making an honest dollar through investments?

Naturally, both in the macrocosm of the economy and the microcosm of season ticket holders, your perspective changes if you are a "have" or a "have-not". It's long been known that the Packers don't make an extra dime off those scalped tickets. Only once have I purchased tickets at above face value, and that was for the 49er playoff game in 1996. I'm lucky enough to have relatives who allow us to purchase tickets from them once or twice a season, so I am better off than many others on that waiting list.

And a good family friend of mine (and true Packer fan) sells off all her tickets each season except for one that she wishes to attend. Why? Simple: she can't afford them. She doesn't want to lose her tickets, but the cost of seven pairs of tickets (not to mention the prices inside the stadium) aren't always feasible when you're working for minimum wage.

So, in some ways, scalping tickets allows the tickets to stay in the hands of the common man, not the well-to-do or brokers who will simply sell them off for their own personal gain.

So, as I sit at #31,384, I realize that there isn't an easy solution for me to move up any faster. I don't think the inheritance policy should be changed (if I have to wait until my deathbed to get the tickets, I'd sure like to be able to at least give them to my kids). And, a blanket "scalper tax" is not only in opposition to what happens with every other ticket for every other sporting event across the nation, it would punish folks like my friend as well as the greedy folks who have more interest in making money than sitting in a cold stadium with 71,294 of their fellow fans to cheer on the Packers.

But, last year's 6-10 record and the economic downturn helped contribute to 192 tickets coming off the list this year...unfortunately, the quickest way for the list to drain itself is going to be to overprice admission for a losing team. And who wants to see that?

Suggestion: I heard not too long ago that you can move up the list in very swift fashion (at the time, I had heard three years) if you request only a single ticket instead of a pair or group of three. The larger the group (and wanting them together) the harder it is to get lucky that someone will drop exactly that many. But, it is far more common for a ticket holder who has a large number of tickets to drop one off in order to save a little money. Good luck.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Collins Playing a Dangerous Game

There was certainly a lot of hubbub yesterday with the return of safety Nick Collins to the OTAs, as the contract holdout has eschewed participating in the voluntary workouts until this week. Of course, some of us felt somewhat relieved, and some of us felt a little more concerned when he was led off the field to work with the rehab group instead of fully watching the install of the 3-4.

For me, perhaps the most interesting quote of the day came from Mike McCarthy, who answered a couple questions about Collins tritely, then finished with this:

(He obviously has a lot to learn with the new defense. Has he been doing a lot on his own?)
I think these questions are more suited for Nick, exactly what he has been doing.


Now, I'm the first to call Mike McCarthy "gruff and ornery", but he typically goes to bat for his players, especially when the media appears to be going after them. This response was short, to the point, and ended any further questions from the gallery in regards to #36.

McCarthy has offered several times over the last few weeks that he understands that the OTAs are voluntary, and that whatever reasons that players have for missing them are up are accepted. His response to being asked about how much Collins is working towards learning the schemata of the new defense sends a message that someone is out of the loop.

I'm glad that the dual position of GM/HC that Mike Sherman held is no longer the structure in Green Bay. I could imagine Sherman up there in this situation, both responsible for the play on the field, and also responsible for negotiating salaries. I'm sure that the media would have gone into Sherman a little more than the guy who is only the head coach.

But McCarthy holding just the head coaching role means that he is only concerned about the play on the field. It's not his job to worry about whether Collins is happy with his contract or if he is deserving of an extension. It is his job to worry about getting all his players on the same page with the new defense. And Collins should be a key piece.

Having your starting free safety missing the install of a new defense is akin to having your quarterback miss the install of a new offense (not that McCarthy would have ever experienced that before, right?). The free safety has to play from behind the front nine and call out the adjustments that need to be made.

Which means, of course, the free safety has to know what it going on, perhaps more than any other defensive player on the field. Given Collins' slow development since his rookie year and McCarthy's own statements that this scheme has massive permutations and relies heavily on communication, it puts into perspective his reply to the question about Collins' efforts to learn the defense.

Clearly, McCarthy's response could mean one of two things:

A) There has been no communication between the coach and Collins, thus he is unaware of what efforts Collins has made on his own towards learning the new scheme; or

B) What communication there has been between the coach and Collins has not been palatable enough for McCarthy to go to bat for him in front of the media.

Given that McCarthy did go to bat for him earlier in the offseason by stated he was excused for a "family situation" (which ended up being his father dying of cancer), it makes option A seem unlikely.

Which would lead me to believe that there is reason to doubt that McCarthy is fully tolerant of not only Collins' lack of participation, but how much he is doing on his own to prepare. This does not bode well for Collins or the defense.

Now, I may be reading far too much into one comment, I admit. But I've commented before on how critical Collins may be to the success of the 3-4 implementation this year. McCarthy knows that his starting free safety needs to know this scheme backwards and forwards.

It is one thing for Collins to withhold his presence in order to finagle more money out of his employer. It is another thing completely for him to shirk his responsibilities and somehow think that he is gaining leverage by not working to learn the defense. Does he think that by not learning the defense that it will make the Packers rush to sign him faster...so he'll start learning it?

I've been critical of Collins' intelligence before. If he is not working on his own to be the best player he can be in such a critical time for the defense, it pretty much seals for me how dense he really is.